Gig review of Snow Patrol + Astrid

Gig Date: Tuesday, 9th March 2004 | 380 page views.

Snow Patrol @ Blank Canvas

By John Harvey

When Morrissey sang the immortal Smiths lyrics: "I should have been wild and I should have been free/but nature played this trick on me" he had in mind the kind of people that are in the groups I'm watching tonight.

It's an interesting thing to consider really... how do some bands get signed while others don't? Why do some shift stacks of albums while others flounder? The last I heard of Snow Patrol they were some Glaswegian Belle & Sebastian boffing understudy. The last couple of months have seen them spiral unimaginable heights with a top three chart hit and some tour of America where Tom Cruise was spotted watching them or something.

I'm invited to this gig tonight by somebody that never usually goes to gigs, hence I know that something sinister is happening with this band. The young indie contingent are out in force tonight, as are the water cooler crew (hipster professionals), so are those strange men in their late twenties/early thirties with the Noel Gallagher haircuts that are often found lurking around these kinds of places and most harrowingly there are even a few of the folks that haunt Wetherspoon's pubs five nights a week in their best shell suit and sovereign rings.

Astrid are a band that have popped up here and there in recent years in the indie nether-nether lands. They start off quite quirky with what sounds like a freshly wrapped variety of pop powered guitar, but gradually they become more and more of a menial audible drudge and by the end of the set are more like hard work to listen to. The singer also keeps telling us to buy their album and t-shirts from the stalls in the corner, like some pushy sales person trying to flog a dead horse... a career in double glazing sir? Get your ass down Joseph's Well and the chances are you'll come across a band better than these guys.

Bring on Snow Patrol. Is it just one of those indie-schmindie clever names or is there really a patrol for snow somewhere? Anyway I can't really understand the appeal or see where the next hit is coming from. They sound like Coldplay being slowly humped by Placebo with the token slowie that sounds like bottom of the sub-Elbow barrel.

There really nice guys and everything and even tell us if we have £15 to buy an Astrid album or t-shirt instead of a Snow Patrol one. But there's nothing new and different on parade tonight, it's from a very safely trodden trad path, the difference is there are many more bands out there that are better at it.

Find related articles: , , , , .

Comments

Noah Baby Food wrote...

Snow Patrol are a complete abortion. Great review. It's just more of the same, inoffensive, soulless cack. Well done for saying so.

Profile | Posted 12th March 2004 at 17:16   back to article

Sam Saunders wrote...

I think the reviewer and Mr Brown have missed the point. Happily offending the musically stunted, Gary Lightbody and crew have been making their kind of music for a long time, and apart from the single have been involved in the successful (sales, musical quality and credibility) Reindeer Seection. Their music has integrity and honesty. You don't have to like it, but it helps if the reviewer does his research. Name-calling needs a bit more substance if it's going to stick

Profile | Posted 14th March 2004 at 10:23   back to article

performingchimp wrote...

Sam - why did they release a bland inoffensive single, then? Do they want people to think they sound like Dido/Coldplay? It scares me how little happens in that song.

Profile | Posted 14th March 2004 at 10:43   back to article

Sam Saunders wrote...

That's a fair point - but in your case it's made from a position of recognising the history - I didn't get that from the review - and Noah Brown's nyahh nyahh comment just wound me up enough to post the reply. Otherwise I wouldn't have bothered. When a band has been making quality music for a long time, a decision to look in a new direction is one worth thinking about and respecting - not just writing off with a stupid insult. "bland and inoffensive" are, in any case, qualities of your hearing, not properties of the music. I would be very surprised if they had decided to be "bland". If they did - stuff 'em.

Profile | Posted 14th March 2004 at 11:11   back to article

performingchimp wrote...

Noah - do you think it would be fair to say that a response to something as "bland" reflects as much on the listener as it does on the music. E.g. if you only ever listened to Sepultura, Robert Jonson and Ornette Coleman, then anything would seem bland. In other words, if you only eat vindaloo, that's fine, but don't expect to be able to taste the wine.

Profile | Posted 16th March 2004 at 00:33   back to article

Sam Saunders wrote...

what a lovely analogy

Profile | Posted 16th March 2004 at 07:07   back to article

Post A Comment

Sorry, you must be signed in to post a comment.

Band Information

Read more about the bands that have been featured in this article.

Other Bands You Might Like

© 1998-2008 Dave Sugden | Credits | Privacy | Mobile Site.